Transcript: Episode 21: Zaw Win Htet, Part 1
Following is the full transcript for the interview with Zaw Win Htet, which appeared on October 20, 2020. This transcript was made possible by Artificial Intelligence (AI) and has not been checked by any human reader. Because of this, many of the words may not be accurate in this text. This is particularly true of speakers who have a stronger accent, as AI will make more mistakes interpreting and transcribing their words. For that reason, this transcript should not be cited in any article or document without checking the timestamp to confirm the exact words that the guest has really said.
Host 00:00
Burma or Myanmar has been a closed country for most of anyone's recent memory. I was blessed being able to move here for work in 2007. And I stayed on after my job finished to explore the Dhamma deeper to my heart's content. As I did so, I found the lived reality on the ground didn't quite match up with how it was being depicted by practitioners and teachers describing it in the West. This isn't so surprising perhaps, unlike Thailand, where Western monks and teachers have spent formative years and even several decades studying and practicing, that was never possible to do here. For many years, it was hard enough to get a visa for seven days. In any case, part of our motivation in this podcast is to provide a more authentic on the ground view of what the Dhamma life really feels like in the golden land. We do this by checking in with dozens of voices whose lives have been shaped by the Burma Dhamma and are willing to take just a moment to share their own personal transformation. So sit back and enjoy what follows and I hope you learned something valuable as well along the way.
01:17
A lot of
Zaw Win Htet 01:58
of all places the Baskin Robbins ice cream parlor off of soy Erie in downtown Bangkok, is the site of a very vivid memory attached for me. On a visa trip to Thailand with my wife several years ago, we emerge from a soak at the unicorn Japanese onsen and decided to grab one of those sweet treats not yet available in the golden land. While she was paying, I was browsing my Facebook feed and happened upon an unusual post in a young Kong group, and perfectly written in English. A young Burmese man was discussing a monastic school in a rural area near his home and upper Burma outside of monywa and inviting backpackers and expats to visit and if possible volunteer, with Myanmar opening up after so many years of being a closed country, things like Internet access, English fluency and cross cultural project building. We're all in the early stages. I'd never seen a post remotely like this before. I immediately got in touch with the author of the post zoan tent. We corresponded a bit by email, and later I sent him dozens of draft pages of the meditators guide to me and more that our team had been working on asking if you wouldn't mind assisting us. This text included the full moon UI area chapters with extensive sections on lady say it has life and teachings, za agreed and he immediately impressed upon us his diligence and attention to detail. He pored over one Burmese history book after another, dug into the Dhamma teachings of local say it as carefully marking up our pages and undertaking his own translations. And as if this were not enough, he traveled in person to many sites to conduct his own interviews and send us his notes and photos. Any foreign meditator who has benefited from spiritual travel to the Manila region from our book or social media posts has all to thank for it. After several years, we finally got the opportunity to meet in person. I was leading a pilgrimage that landed in monywa and he met us there. We spent a day in his hometown of changle, arriving just as his family made a large offering to a number of nuns at their home and we joined in the good wishes and happily dug into the delicious food. He then drove us around giving us an enthralling tour of little bygone or the Omnia region near his home. After years of corresponding electronically his joyful presence only increased my esteem for him, and I was happy that a small chunk or community had such a brilliant star in its midst. After that, occasionally on Facebook, I would see a photos all had taken a treading on Pagoda, or some other Yangon landmark, and I would gently chide him via email for taking yet another trip to the big city without looking this up. I eventually exacted a promise that on his next such visit, he would come to our home for sure. Fortunately for all you podcast listeners, that was after our recording studio was set up. true to his humble nature, offered over a dozen reasons why others would be a more worthwhile guest than himself. But he finally acquiesced when he was convinced that his involvement could increase the faith of even one foreign practitioner and the truth of the Buddhist teachings. For someone whose life is a true testament of service towards others, it's not surprising This is the hook that brought him in zahlen Ted is curious about the world and does not just accept what he is told or sees at face value. traits that are unfortunately not that common in a country whose education system has traditionally been neglected, and at times even actively suppressed. He actively seeks out learned people and listens carefully to what they have to say. And he reads voraciously. Add to this a special ability, and frankly one which I'm envious of, to synthesize, retain and communicate what he learns in an extremely coherent way. A little prompt here or a small nudge There is also needed to be off and running. And what he has to share about his country is well worth hearing. There are some pretty incredible stories and what follows some inspiring, some dramatic, some legendary and some will almost unbelievable. I'm so glad that we were able to record his voice, and that it's now available for you all to benefit from, but don't take my word for it. Listen up and decide for yourselves.
Host 05:54
So welcome for the first time in our place. I've been trying to get you here for years, I always see that you're I see on your Facebook that you're just leaving Yangon or just in Yangon a short time while we say no, why don't you tell me we want to have you over. And finally, this time, you said that you were coming for some event in Yangon. And you had a day to spend with us. And I was so excited and the studio was set up and I can pull you in here. We, we just met once before this in person when I came to monywa, and then the chungu. We've been in touch for years over the internet. And it was such a delight to meet a couple years ago in person and spend that time together. And then it was great to continue corresponding. And I'm really glad that you were able to come this time and that we could hang out outside the studio. And then we can also get a chance to check in with you here because I think the story that you're going to tell and some of the background that you have to share is just really great to be able to, to have people out there be able to listen in.
Zaw Win Htet 06:56
It is my pleasure to come here. And thank you for your invitation as well.
Host 07:01
Yeah. And you know, we should also say that our our relationship and involvement began with you really helping us out in the meditators guidebook. You're as I mentioned, you're from monywa, which is famous for the lady say at our region, also some of his disciples, such as Moni and seda, were in that area Maha Bodhi Bodhi the townsite. Right, he's he's also there, and you're from Chow Lu. And in the meditators guidebook, you were absolutely of great help, and being able to provide us a lot of very exact information about some of the history and the culture and the monasteries and the practices in that region that made those chapters much better. So that was that was our, the beginning of our relationship. And then since then, we've seen the work you're doing at your monastic school and your region. And maybe let's just start hearing a little about the history of your village Chow. Ooh, where is it? And why is it important?
Zaw Win Htet 08:02
As you can see, Chow is a small town. And but in history is a huge history. It has a huge history since the era of again, so it was studded. But in our writings, it was it became premise, after the blue one composed by CLG, the kangaroo mine, who is the national leader, and the teachers of general Allison, and also the Keanu. And the other thing that can be bad. So But anyway, since we were young, we hear a lot of stories about the history of our downtown. You can hear chow chow means the stream whoo means take fast like that. So in our oral histories, my grandma always said every night about our history game, Jen said maybe you have heard about, again, Jesse Jesse ran away from from began kendon. Because he made his, he made his kin and Murata angry, and then he ran away from the capital, and that he was hiding from the bullies of the gang Oita. At that time, he ran to he came to chow eight years. And then he has he, he loved many places behind his his running away. So in Chow area he ran completed, completed with a stream can be used by the zombie and zombie, but at the time, the stream the water in the stream runs goes first before him. So why he became the king? He named this village town because the stream piece him stream beats him.
Host 10:13
Right? And for someone who doesn't know a lot about me Mr geography where How could you describe where Chung Hua is located?
Zaw Win Htet 10:20
Everybody knows Mandalay, right. So uppermill Obama, mentally mentally it was the capital city, so everybody may know, but in the west of Mandalay and it is two and a half hour drive from Mandalay to the west, and to the Northwest region, it is in the lower region of lower part of the region.
Host 10:49
Okay, so it's about two and a half hour by car northwest of Mandalay, which is in upper Myanmar?
Zaw Win Htet 10:54
Yes, yes.
Host 10:55
Yeah. Right. And you would reference that the origins of chapungu come from a subject of King Noah tough from bygone who was running away from the king to escape his life. What years are we talking about? At
Zaw Win Htet 11:10
around 880?
Host 11:13
Around 880? So you trace your villages formation to around 880 180? Yes, right. Okay. And can you clarify again that So chungu means a quickly moving stream? Is that correct? Yeah, it goes fast. A stream that goes fast. Yeah, it goes
Zaw Win Htet 11:31
fast. Before before King and King James it
Host 11:34
also the the king that was escaping. King annoyed that he named it the stream that runs fast, because
Zaw Win Htet 11:45
it just they ran away from Ghana later. Because he made he fell in love with the bronzes. Who is given by the by another game as present to gain again, or that became angry on game gensets or loved breast cancer.
Host 12:08
Yes, yes. Right. So to escape a love triangle of the princess that both kings had fell in love with. He went to chungu and started and he named it the, the he named the village, the stream that runs fast because the the stream was running faster than him was that way.
Zaw Win Htet 12:25
Yes. Yes. It is a love story. A good love story when we hear for the children. When we were young.
Host 12:34
I see I see. Right. And that was a story. Your grandmother told you. Yeah, the village Yeah, that's great. So okay, so that's the founding. So then take us through the next several centuries of what happens in chungu.
Zaw Win Htet 12:46
Actually, Chung who was at the time, a village, but after gain currency, in the, in the last days of the gas era. There is also a king called King Joshua.
Host 13:02
And what what century is this?
Zaw Win Htet 13:04
It is also 100 years later, 100 years later only. So at the time, King Joshua and his mother ran from began to Chung again, because his father was assassinated, buying, buying, buying, buying the others. So his father lost his throne, and also his father passed away. And then again, Joshua and his mother came to chow. And then they were hiding in a monastery, near the Mendoza village near the mothers of village. So in that monastery, one, his mother was hiding from the danger of the key, who grabbed the throne, from his husband, from her husband. So, he he breed at the border and he offered a rope to the Buddha statue, and that Buddha, and he, he wished, if her son became a king, he he will come back and rebuild the Buddha and he will offer as your guilt the Buddha with the full goal, either. So and then, one. The one the family, the mother and her son went back to began after years, and then they were welcomed by Nick Gonzalez and Hassan became a king and King jazva was very famous for his literature in Tibetan Buddhist literature for three baskets of Buddhist literature. So, he also came back and guilds the pagoda with full gold. And then he erected and stone inscription, which is still existing till now in Nevada. bond that in the equation it is says in this area chungu Area B B missionary different reasons like the lower at the time what was called low but oh lawan at the time was called lava, lava and also Obama and also currently amazingly lived. And that's true is corruption. We can see this until now until today in a burger festival in in a village called Kala g in the village there every day every after the Buddha festival they are still dancing Korean traditional dance
Host 15:44
right so this is highlighting some of the diversity of Myanmar people listening might not know what a diverse country Myanmar is the Bomar people are the majority but there are so many other ethnic minorities that live there now and have lived there before and as you're discussing from this yeah inscription on the pagoda even that description evidence strong evidence right that of the diversity that's always been here Yeah. And so you're it's also interesting because your village Chung Ooh, it sounds like it had some repeated stories of Kings from begone running away for safety and taking refuge there. So it hadn't had this relationship and actually today it's it's called kind of a cute nickname of Little Dragon right?
Zaw Win Htet 16:29
It is again,
Host 16:30
yeah. Why is it copper?
Zaw Win Htet 16:31
Yeah, in our map, you can see our area chungu and began East we can see straight up and down. so closely looking south north and south trade. So crossing the river and God river and you can at the time be bear from began capital were rich our region. So there is also a village God Dong Bella where the Kings justice Queen was born. So you that that area is called Lidl again.
Host 17:10
So this is Chung Chow, right? And why is it called Little bugan?
Zaw Win Htet 17:14
Little Bryggen because there are many stupors and tumbles and ancient pagodas like in beggin So, it is spreading around but you have to have enough time to visit all the companies how much time? Yeah, three, four days. You have to because it is spreading, right in this village and other religious later. Yeah, right.
Host 17:42
And do you get foreign tourists every year coming to see these sites?
Zaw Win Htet 17:46
I often take my guest from low gear or from foreign countries. I usually I am proud of digging them to this idiot.
Host 18:01
Yeah, and you are a great local guide and historian you definitely take care of the people that come but do you just been a place with that kind of history? Do you tend to see a lot of foreigners tourists walking around and seeing the sights is that common
Zaw Win Htet 18:17
in Ladybug area? foreigners come very, very occasionally. So generally very Yeah, it is very rare to see the foreigners because it is
Host 18:30
off the beaten track. Right. Right. And that's so anyone listening to this Dhamma visitor or otherwise who's thinking to come to me and mark this is a great travel hint of a really special place to go when I visited there and you were my guide and showed me all these places and imbibe them with local history. I remember thinking boy, if I was just in Myanmar one time I would almost rather come here then the gone Of course McGann has that great history but with it you also get the touts that are trying to sell you things and all the other tourists and all the other commotion and this was just a really peaceful and magnificent set of ruins one after the other after the other that was was was just empty for you to wander through so it's a it's a really special place with a lot of history and significance to be able to see today
Zaw Win Htet 19:20
of course it is yes
Host 19:21
yeah and you know most of those stories because you've you've spent your childhood hearing them and then you also have a curious mind you've you've read books, you've talked to local historians, you your family has told you things you've been to all these sites so you're really a repository of information about some of these great places
Zaw Win Htet 19:37
Yeah, my my ambition to do read the books, especially histories and but especially biographies. These passion was born by my grandmother. Actually, if I have to see here, in this point, if I have to see about My passion to read books is studying from my grandma. He always tells me the stories in the nighttime. And then the first very interesting story he started to, he started to tell me was senior topical attorney. In that book, it is about the life of Buddha. And then every night every night time, he always dealt different different stories. So and then I also mixed questions to her. And he tried this, he trained me how to read. And okay, you can find this story, you can find this history in this book, he guided me to read the books. So and after that, when I read more and more books, I read about the history of my area, and also about the connection, relationship with began. dynasties. So like that. So that's why the information as much as I know, and I also would like to share with the others. One, we started to use the computer in 2009. And at the time, not not as as LCD monitor. My father bought me for after I passed matriculation exam, and I use the computer. And then I think 2011, I started to use the internet. And I also wrote in the wiki video about the history some of you might have
Host 21:46
read or you you wrote, I wrote so you so the the Wikipedia entry discussing Chang Wu was written by you from Yeah, wow. Wow. So that's really impressive, because I think for listeners out there that don't know about Myanmar's recent history and access to information, you're really ahead of the curve. I mean, 2012 13 is when the country started to open up, the access to internet was very seldom before that just a few years before we're talking the mid, the mid 2000s there's almost not Wi Fi anywhere in the country, there's almost not access to any kind of internet. So just after the first sprinklings of internet are opening up before the country is really opened, you're already finding your way on to Wikipedia of all places, and using that to be able to share information in English about your village history, which you've spent your life learning about from your grandmother and from books and from going there. So this this passion to to learn this information and share it sounds like it came from a very young age on your part.
Zaw Win Htet 22:51
Yes, yes.
Host 22:52
Can you say more about that?
Zaw Win Htet 22:54
Yeah, about this, I I like to tell about the history another history of my area, it is a mean, I mean, so now this is another village another village close to town also about off live again. Right right. So in a mean village. Everybody every mama knows with IRA, you will also see a road named with Sarah
Host 23:26
sugar younger. So who was with our
Zaw Win Htet 23:29
with our, what was a national hero and who passed away after his hands for hunger strike, or for more than 150 days after hunger strike, he passed away in, in British colonial period. So as a time old there are only two there were only two monks who, who was against the British rule. And one of them is will demand from Rakhi. And another one is from our region with our so
Host 24:10
since the British ruler, since a British ruler, took shoes on the platform of the vocoder and then it there was a protest against him. And also Finally, it led to the protest against the British rule. Right so to back up a little bit, Burmese pagodas and monasteries, some monasteries, but certainly pagodas are places where you have to remove your shoes out of respect in order to to go and the British did not like removing their shoes, they weren't wearing sandals, they were often wearing these big Western military boots, considered it kind of a sign of humiliation and submission and it took time and it wasn't their culture. And so they there was this big cultural miscommunication and conflict where they insisted on wearing their shoes, even on sacred Buddhist pagodas. And the Burmese nationalist movement used this as a protest to start protests about the disrespect for Burmese Buddhist culture. And we Zahra was one of the people behind this particular point of protest. Is that correct?
Zaw Win Htet 25:23
Yes, he came from from your village. Not Not Not only that, for that, for that case, but also he also led many activities later for the national independence. And also before dinner onsens before dinner on set and also before yanda can be Bey.
Host 25:44
Right, right. So he was one of the the first nationalist leaders that the later ones looked up to. Yes, yeah. And he was a monk as well. Yes. Right. And he came from your village as well. That's why that is
Zaw Win Htet 25:54
still until now, there is some beliefs that monks should also participate in politics. Deal No, in among them, monks. Okay.
Host 26:08
Can you say more about what you mean by that? For example,
Zaw Win Htet 26:12
there are two, two sides. One side is, monks do not participate in the politics. And another side, monks shirt, because even with our and wildomar, participated for the national interest for the national independence. So they they are they were very good examples to protect our race to protect our country. So the issue the examples, and that's, I suppose, monks, should they should participate in politics and political activities?
Host 26:49
Right, right. So there's this question that monks, the the job of monks is to be a monastic, to not be concerned about the changing of the outside world and to because the world is always going to change this is the Buddhist teachings, but their concern should be on ensuring the Dhamma does not go away and teaching the next generation? And then there's another view that, well, no, the monks are looking after the social welfare of the people and of the overall race. And if if there's a major problem taking place of those people, then they also have to serve that. And this is interesting, because you're referencing one of the probably the not one of but the monk who involved themselves in politics more than almost any any other of that time period, until today. And he came from your village, and he was an example of the one side, it's then interesting to contrast that with another great Burmese monk who came from just outside your village and monywa, just maybe 50 years earlier. And this is of course, Lady Santa. So lady say it was the most popular and famous monk of the colonialist era, one of the most important ones and from your and we should also say you again, have a personal connection with Lady say it is legacy, because many of your family members are involved with ladies monasteries today. Can you share a little more about that?
Zaw Win Htet 28:17
As I already said, My grandma is the main character of this story. So she was also farmers. So in the flames of Lady Theodore from jungle, she was Yes, she was French Oh, okay. She lived her husband is also a staff, a government stuff of railway station. And then one the one they lived in Montreal, at that time, that is zero D was traveling around the country, not to eat the meat or God, beef, not to eat beef like that, too. At the time. There are also diseases happening all around the country. And then there is a road he traveled around and made the teachings do the Bieber not to eat vif because they are also benefactors for the promise because our country is agricultural country. So my my grandma also listened in one of his Dhamma talk, and then in person in person. And also he was he has also seen general awesome in person as well. Alright, so he listened in the d'amato. And also, he also has data now I have the books written by Larry Sergey, regarding about the objections to eat beef like the other time, especially in the traditional Miramar before the British came in. My grandma said my grandma even said, as, as the as the book as per the books. He said before British came in. And yamabe usually eat vegetables. And sometimes there might be some hunters who ran into the forest and the the contract Revis and just more enemies, but after the British came in, and then the they also brought a culture to eat chicken, and also pork and also beef like that, at that time, beef was very popular in Namibia and we like to eat beef a lot. And then farmers are losing their guns. And then Larry, Sergey steder to, and also at the time diseases were happening. Then Larry Sergey started to, to make the demodex and teachings to the Bieber, not to eat fish. And also my grandma was also one of the disciples of Larry Sergey. So although we are my parents, and even myself, and our farmers that are still now we don't like to eat fish. What's wonderful, and, and so your, your grandmother was a disciple of lady said,
Host 31:12
she attended some of his sermons, did she tell you anything about her personal recollection of seeing lady in person?
Zaw Win Htet 31:20
He told me once that one, actually, I have never seen Of course, Lady theology. But I, in my very early age of my young who life I saw, I was under the, under the teachings of Mahabharata, Thomas era. So what she said is, look at mahabodhi, the tongue zero, and his face also looks like mahallesi. So, that's what he remembered. And also
Host 31:59
his face, his face his face. Yes, yes.
Zaw Win Htet 32:01
And also, one she lived in Moscow. And at the time, there was no rain in, in Montreal, and then lady Sara Lee want to go pro to from one industry to another. And then he claimed he was the toilers of the monks, Buddhist monks. He always respects the community of Sangha. So after, after he did these merit, these, this good deed, and then he made a resolution to rain, and then it rained. So this is my grandma also believed in this story very much.
Host 32:46
And she was alive during this time. Yes, yes. Yeah. And lady say it was from this region of moneywatch. Hungary where you're from this is a hard place to live. This is a hard climate. It's history is relatively new, the people haven't there haven't been a large community, or city that's, that that's that survived for a long time, because it is a harder place to live. So, so lady being from that town, he knew of those conditions, but he still would go back and spend much time there. Yes. Yeah. And so it's also interesting just to reflect on that you if we reflect on yours and my background and how we came together, your grandmother is a lady say a disciple and that runs in your family. And and you remember her recollections lady say it of course, through his lineage ended up the Dhamma ended up coming to sn Goenka who taught around the world and had these passionate centers. I learned the passionate meditation in a center of of sn Goenka tradition in Japan, which eventually brought me to me and Mar that practice. And so it's interesting,
Zaw Win Htet 34:00
right, so you, the generation of mahalo at zero, we can say new new generations or maladies,
Host 34:08
right? So you're you're coming here from your grandmother's stories of witnessing lady in person and the the Dhamma lessons coming to you more or less directly from through her as a vehicle and her experience of being with him. Whereas I came from I'm from America, but I practiced in Japan initially for those two years. That's that was the thing that brought me to want to be in Myanmar was that tradition and that practice? And so I'm coming on the other end, but then there's that thread connecting all of us and your grandmother and Lady and Glencoe. So that's that's really wonderful.
Zaw Win Htet 34:40
Yeah, Nothing happens without their formal goals.
Host 34:44
Right. Right. Right. So I want to get back to initially why I brought up lady said, we were talking about UI Zara being this nationalist monk who was very much using his monastic status, to want to be involved in worldly issues. While you also had another great monk living in your area at the time of British colonialism, and how would you characterize what lady was doing with his being a monk living in colonial times, how would you contrast that with what we Zahra was choosing to do?
Zaw Win Htet 35:19
As I already said, We Salah is the national hero for the later people. And mahallesi Raji was the monk who brightest and who follow up the but only in his writings and teachings and also to propagate propagate the Buddhism and Buddhist teachings to the bread and share the Buddha's teachings in Myanmar language assembly for the poor, they're very, very reputable, and we serve at the point of who we are, if he also as for me personally, he if he did not participate in political activities, for example, to protect the the to protect the Myanmar gotcha meme or Buddhist culture, which we respect not to wear the shoes either. So, if he did not protect the gotcha, and if he didn't know, did not dead, if he did not dare do we against the British ruler, the history where we change to another form either to and bommies gotcha, where we also probably disappeared like that. So, anyway, for the point of the fact that monks should not should participate should participate in political activities. I would give you an example. As I already said, I my former my very early age of life was under the teachings of mahabodhi did homesale here since it is candidate, let me say, Actually, I will not like to talk about my personal story, but I also would like to, to share because foreigners also should know the rebirth and also and Poma lives in in English language. So, I have already determined Theodore has a brother named Judy Junya, who does Ania
Host 37:40
and we should say this this has no relation to say rotation near from the shore human tradition which some meditators No no, this is
Zaw Win Htet 37:48
a different part is this different person who does India is mahabodhi detonics era una era does parada, younger brother, and one Buddha was alive. And they were very familiar and friendly to us. And then one day visited my house and then the the monks, the true monks, to my parents, that I was their mother in a former life, oh, wow, goodness. So, this is a relationship with also anger and say, because I followed F, no s tradition, but from my deep heart, I followed the Buddhist teachings. No, no, because my parents are Buddhist, because I was also I also had many relationships with the Buddhist teachings and also Buddha's disciples, who are the monks. So anyway, so mahalo bodhichitta, I will give you an example for, for the fact that monks should participate in political activities. For example, no, dryly. This is also another example. One in Deuteronomy seven, actually Indu danza five and six. It was I as far as I remember, it was very, very hard time and every broadcast every course. Right Bri prices are getting higher at the time, and then be we're having difficult lives daily lives because the prices were increased a lot. And also before 2007. Revolution, revolution, my man, my man and his, my memory Hakkasan, frontal, one to mahabodhi john Cerro de to offer do offer meal as a very early breakfast in the dorm time around four o'clock after five o'clock around five or four decently later. So anyway, at the time And as far as I remember, in those times, when the prices were increased a lot, them harborage on Sierra did not accept any offerings and any donations from the BP because he feels very busy on the people, he doesn't want to make the Bieber a burden for him like that. So after that, when the prices go down, and then when we talked about it with theologie. And then he said, I am also one of the society. I'm also one of the poorest society. So this is politics, also related to every buddy, everybody in the society. That's why, and in this from this point, I'm also supporting the fact that monks also should participate in a proper way in political activities. So not only as like, lady said of God, and He is the role model of reversing our meditation and every other Buddhist teachings.
Host 41:10
Right, so how would you characterize mahabodhi town say it has involvement in society? How was he being involved in the society of the day?
Zaw Win Htet 41:21
All right, at some hidden stories, I send I think he should you can guess what I mean, but I don't want to show you all the story, poverty, the town zero set to our family as a question to our family, and be very, very, very poor in the dark times, as we say, in the before will democratic transition. So he said, he has our family to you, like, even apart, even about does not like to be arrested in the cage. So what he also usually tried to participate in political activities, not as a rally not as a very issue of only very hidden, very behind behind the best vision. He was also telling to release the brazenness
Host 42:31
right, very subtle ways. So there's different ways that it might not be so much a question should monks participate in the outside world or not? It's more a question to what extent and how are they participating? Because you're showing very subtle and careful ways that he's been involved? Exactly. Yes. Yeah. Right. So we talked about a little lady said, many people are familiar with him, and you gave a brief background of UI Zahra. We've talked a little bit about mahabodhi townside. He's extremely well known in Myanmar, one of the most well known monks of the last 50 years, surely. But I think for meditators outside of me and Mar they've probably had very little access with his teachings and his life. Can you give us a little bit of background about him?
Zaw Win Htet 43:16
Can I tell the biography stories of his life? Sure. In brief,
Host 43:22
sure. And his teachings Yeah,
Zaw Win Htet 43:24
yes. And actually, my body this town's hero is very well known for his podamos de pavana, meditation and what that means, that means kind of contemplation, a kind of meditation, which records the added use of Buddha who is free from defilements who is pre from Mandal impurities, so do brightest. And now we can get our clear mind, when we are regarding his deduce, we are also added at the moment at the very short moment, we are also free from anger, free from danger and free from worries especially personally for me, every time I get worries, every day I get very angry, I usually pray this Buddha knows that the governor so why he did pray this burden so dibaba, it is doodle his biography life. So in his very young age, at the age of 20, at the age of 20, yes, he, he suffered. He suffered tuberculosis when he was studying Buddhist literature's in Baku in chungu. In in Mandalay at the time he went to the doctor and he Due to treat to take treatment for his disease, but the doctor knew that he, he his disease was very, extremely suffering. He was very thin and also his very his his very thing. So he is very coughing. So, he said, Actually, he did not want to tell him that you are almost dying. That's what my average from zero to our family members. So he doesn't actually he didn't know what to say go back and you're almost dying. But he he said to the monk, he said to our leaders on zero and please let the young monk you go back and is there any Are there many hills in your native area in your region? Yes. And if yes, so, you please go up the hills and walk and also do breathe in fresh air like that. And the time he he wanted to his father's village who is around which is around Manjula and Chung. So he went up the hills, and he had a very hard life. And he has only one roof. And he lived in a only very small height. When the rain comes, he was what when the rain stopped and when the sun rises, his rope Gods ride very hard life. So And finally, after one year, he went back to the doctor, and he checked and then he was completely feeling well. So what he usually makes like a joke to our family as a friendly manner. He usually says that I want to, I am afraid to die afraid of death, I am afraid of death. That's why I did meditation a lot. I do meditation a lot. He always said that. And also he is disbelief also accepted by all the disciples of mahabodhi to Tom monastery as well.
Host 47:31
And he had royal blood didn't he? Pardon, he was connected to the royal family wasn't he?
Zaw Win Htet 47:37
Actually it will be related to the reverse and pomar lives. So, he, he has he won he suffered the disease and he he thought he was also dying. And then finally, he made a mind if I am dying, I will offer my life to Buddha. And then he made a pilgrimage to Mandela Hill and at the bottom or Mandalay Bay, and he found a monk. Now who sorrow His name is his monk who name is Nanda Doria, the monk lived like a crazy monk. And he lived in very dodgy robes. And he lived in the knee or his monastery was surrounded by bushes at the time. He wasn't in the monastery. And when he saw the monk, and he breathed and he offered a hue he want he said to him, I want to take the refuge of you and do take meditation method to learn from you how to meditate, either he learned from him. That monk is the grandson of gaming though and the British colony. British government also offered him an ordinary award nangang hora de angama Reza means that achievement of Sangha Society of monks like that, so anyway, he he did not accept the announcer nonzero as to not upset mahabodhi the tone zero at once. Do we his disciple, and then he tried many he tested many things. Finally, he tried to one test. He bought a dead body, many, many days, or that the dead body of a dog. And then he put on the table and then he had lunch after he collected his food. And then my buddy john said Oh, the young monk also was sitting and also having lunch but He could not tolerate to we do this smell of the dead bodies on the dock and then he oh oh my master why not you abandoned this dead body of the dogs and he pulled away. So now you said to him Oh, very good man Very good, thank you ladies Thank you are very good except the dead body or dog that is up the desk or the dead body or dog like that
Host 50:31
that was a test what that was a test what was it testing him on
Zaw Win Htet 50:35
test to test his patience to test his tolerance to be at a cyber or him if he is very enthusiastic to learn how to meditate. He just want to try to test him.
Host 50:53
So did he pass the test or not
Zaw Win Htet 50:56
only the last test with a dead body or dog
Host 50:59
right? This was like a super practice
Zaw Win Htet 51:01
and the other the other the other Deathwatch he passed the other test and also the noun cod is very Australian, in his extremely hungry I see in his radius of living in the forest, living under the tree living nor living in the house not living in the building. to tango practice, do danga Yes, exactly.
Host 51:29
mahabodhi to town Sarah,
Zaw Win Htet 51:31
what do you do? also one of the hills and also practice meditation, and especially porosity Bhavana. And he came relieved from his disease.
Host 51:46
I see. And today mahabodhi to town say it as that's that's his name, right
Zaw Win Htet 51:52
but yes, exactly. Right. Yeah, yes. Okay,
Host 51:56
so today, Bodhi to town Santa in monywa his monastery is pretty unique. There's some some features that are very unusual other monasteries Can you describe that?
Zaw Win Htet 52:06
Yeah. Actually body the tongue means body means wisdom, insight, knowing body means and the Tao means one doctor, one one he was suffering the disease he was living in a very small hut and the bank, bow tree and the banyan tree since the bow tree is the banyan tree is under the banyan tree under the Bodhi tree Buddha attained enlightenment. So, we also pay respect to do the trick to this type of tree. So, when he was living in a small hut under the tree and very small, very very small trees grown under the big trees, this is a good sign and then at the time be better thought be better oh this is not a good sign and then a bad for him Okay, it is not a good sign and if I have to die, if that because I am growing these trees, smaller trees in the bots and to grow to grow the trees if I have to die, I don't care and I will die. And then he started to grow the trees. And then he was hated as he was also relieved. And then he was invited by his by his anger by him by his father's village people one his anger monk passed away in a monastery where the BodyTalk monastery is now. So, anyway, he requests he asked the village people, villagers, if you can give me a land to grow the trees, I will move I will accept your invitation I will recite in this mode in your monastery. But if you cannot give a land I will not. So and this the villagers by purchase small acres of land and finally he grew the trees both trees and with a half off now with a Otto who is his master. Now with the hover his master and he tried to grow 1000s and 1000s of trees. And then he was he became well known as political theater there monk of 1000 boo trees
Host 54:37
I see and now
Zaw Win Htet 54:39
he has he had grown 10 1000s or trees when he was alive.
Host 54:45
So he surpassed his goal.
Zaw Win Htet 54:47
Yeah, but the name the name or the name of the ministry did not was not changed into body damage.
Host 54:54
Yeah, so there's many body trees if you go today,
Zaw Win Htet 54:57
yes. Right. Yeah, you will see from the The second world's largest, the world's second largest provider, study Buddha and also from the mountains, you will see very green areas of the topic a hot area. In that area. He developed them Lake, he developed the dams and the electricity and schools he built a lot of development.
Host 55:22
So this whole region was impacted with him there the people's lives became better with some of these initiatives that he was doing and, and then also, as you mentioned, he he built there's a standing Buddha, Reclining Buddha and a city in Buddha, all three of which are gigantic in size, approaching from miles and miles around you just see the countryside, you see the heat kind of boiling off the countryside, as it as you look down the horizon and then far, far away, you see these images kind of joking above this, this vast, vast rural landscape. Yes, yes. Yeah. But that was his design.
Zaw Win Htet 56:02
Yeah, he designed and he designed and he made the drawings by himself. And one very interesting story is he usually wanted to build the Buddha statues and pagodas in in which inside India is a hollow type, but that's unusual in Myanmar that is his non usual to do Myanmar. But this is his own wish and his own design.
Host 56:35
Why did he want him Hello?
Zaw Win Htet 56:36
Okay, before I for example, when he started to build a big pagoda at the bottom of the hill, where the standard Buddha and Reclining Buddha and is built at the bottom of the hill, double Buddha that you will see the Golden Buddha. Like Shwedagon Pagoda. Dabba Gouda is the first Giant Buddha he built. So he wanted to build a hollow type inside the Buddha at the time he designed but one of his friends who is also became famous being Beulah, Congleton, zero and he wondered, he doesn't want own please do not build a hollow dive inside, only build like a solid type. And he he never he never made a quarrel to him because he is like a brother for him. So and then, before the start, they started the construction. And then that monk was invited by Bueller Bueller monastery to recite and then he moved there and Mahajan, zero could build on his own will, the holotype. The holiday wine he wants to build holiday is like insight inside the inside the guru or inside the Buddha. It is like a cliff in Yama, traditional traditions and books. And also in booms. In the Himalayas, the Buddha, a hertz has lived in the cave, Nanda mu cave, like in Ananda dumbbell impact. So he also wanted to build the holodeck inside.
Host 58:39
So we wanted it to feel like a meditative cave. Yes. And there's also one of the statues has the 31 planes of existence, right? Yes. So you can actually as you walk up the statue to get the view, you pass from the hill realms to the highest diva realm. Yes, yeah. And I haven't been there. But I guess each Each floor has information about that realm.
Zaw Win Htet 58:58
Yes. I was. I was thinking to translate those writings, but it couldn't happen yet.
Host 59:07
He was also influenced by weights of practice, is that correct? Exactly. Yeah. Can you explain what weights is
Zaw Win Htet 59:13
very interesting. Because my family was to follow his path. So without Brady's is another type of another type or radius and nor mainly connected to Tera vaada Buddhism, let me know say, it comes from higher now whatever, let me know see this. But it's all in the belief of our leukerbad around Mahabharata ministry and also the discipline in the society in the community of the disciples are mahabodhi to zero with a pride This is also a very, very good how fu mud To celebrate the Buddha's teachings to, to the great, amazing things. For example, he could, he did or he developed this area stanny Buddha, not only poda not only campus and monastery but also the schools and many other things he developed. And also his monasteries are also in Yangon. And also in the US in New York, in England, so many monasteries he could build anyway. So he could do this with the help of his apprentice as well. To say exactly, he landed, not only meditation but also with the brightest from una and Adria. Then, now say Otto, who is the grandson of commando
Host 1:00:55
what type of weights or practice did you do?
Zaw Win Htet 1:00:58
Okay, me, how can we? Yes, okay. Me, actually in in a Western in the West. I also have read books about alchemy, and uden also tried I read about that, but not sure. So anyway, it might be it will. It is very, very different from the western alchemy in our aura artist stories, as I already said, my grandmother's and nighttime stories, our kingdom of Nehemiah was built by was very, very flourishing with Buddhism, would they have or she is our governor? Who is the who is a wizard, and who tried with our brightest. And then his eyes were taken out taken off by Nick King, because he didn't know best to make to make the gold from his alchemy. alchemy. So anyway, began the issue moo, moo, moo, moo, moo, moo. Amin's, go, rain, silver rains in beggar. That's why today, we basically believe that that time that ancient people could build a lot of temples and vocoders with the help of Ghana, who is a waiter?
Host 1:02:26
So it was the it was the wachesaw practitioners that allowed the Theravada Buddhist practice to become established for the first time and then flourish throughout Myanmar. This is what you're saying?
Zaw Win Htet 1:02:38
Yes, yes. Since that time, in a chemist in via modulation alkemist history, we can say that it status from an era.
Host 1:02:49
Right, right. And so there's the weights, conversation. This is a whole other topic that we don't have time to develop delve into now, but it is another kind of practice practice that exists in Myanmar in here with Bodie, the town said, we see someone who is practicing Vipassana and other techniques from the scriptures, and as you talked about the budino Sati and, and other meditative practices, but he's also a weight sub practitioner and so it's not quite so black and white in terms of what he represents or what he's practicing,
Zaw Win Htet 1:03:28
he has the main essence, and the main essence of his use of alchemy is not just not only alchemy, as you said combination of both and lucidity, parvana, meditation and also with alchemy combination. So the main essence is not for greed, not for our Libby's family, bro bless, not for our, for our world, but only it should be brightest for spreading the Buddha's teachings and so invisible tradition with us, come have you to celebrate Buddha's teachings and also to bedevil good as stupid attemp is like,
Host 1:04:16
right, right. And this could be something that for foreigners who are practicing some traditional form of a passion outside in their countries, and they they have this image of Myanmar being the place where all these compassionate techniques were maintained and then shared. Learning about the diversity of practice here and yeah, different levels of, of engagement that that that exist, it can sometimes be confusing seen where it all fits together. Yeah. Where how it all makes a complete picture.
Zaw Win Htet 1:04:47
Yeah, that's for the brain as it will also be a very different brightness as well.
Host 1:04:54
Right. Right. And so mahabodhi telling say it was one of the great monks and teachers of the last 50 years, certainly very recognizable in Myanmar. And you say that he and his brother informed your family that you were actually the mother from a previous lifetime? How did that when actually I should say when did you learn that? How old were you, when you were informed of that and how did that make you feel
Zaw Win Htet 1:05:20
as a relationship with a Buddhist monk in Myanmar, we live to have to have a chai and a monk to have a son as a monk, as a monk for his whole life, it is a very, very great, very great place for her or for the appearance, it is also a good deed. So, the parents cannot go to the hell are the parents cannot live like Canada, it is a good distance, it is a good deed. There are Buddhists who has caught the sun as a monk and as a man and then they can reborn they can take a have they can read they can be reborn as a human being like that to us as I have not, I have I cannot see any information because I cannot know these very, very mysterious thing this is a mysterious thing but only to do here only to hear his scenes. And our family also believed that that's why we have to to code Maris Cody's more and more and more, and also to support the Buddha sasana Buddha's teachings to the Buddha Dhamma Sangha, the monks, either. So this is our personal belief from How old were you when you were informed?
Host 1:06:56
2626? Yeah, was did it come as a shock to you? Or did it come as a surprise or a shock to learn this?
Zaw Win Htet 1:07:03
You mean, I was shocked to hear I was reborn. I was his from his mother.
Host 1:07:11
Yeah, were were you shocked to hear that?
Zaw Win Htet 1:07:14
Actually. I will say completely. My one my mother had me in her pregnancy. And then they said oh, I said to other disciples, to the, to the to the other BBA in Maja Don't lie. He, I even met her in the pagoda festival very recently. He said at the time, no, X ray, no ultrasound. So my mother didn't know, take ultrasound at the time. So but Theodore said that, well, we have why. And he said this, he will be the most beautiful. And then the lady goes his mask as a belief or his mother. But as for me, instead of the I was shocked, but I i since I knew this information. I practice the Buddha's teachings more and more in my daily life. It is the most beautiful means I have to make my mind as the most beautiful possible.
Host 1:08:31
right? If the seda and his brother knew this, from the time that you were in the womb, and then after being born, I wonder if it affected the way they related to you? Did they relate to you with this warmth and affection and gratitude of having been your mother and a former incarnation? Or did they put this knowledge somewhere else and recognize you for what you were in this life has been a young boy like any other young boy and they're, they're a monk who has a responsibility and duty to any young boy they meet how how did this knowledge affect their relationship with you?
Zaw Win Htet 1:09:10
Ah, they that's since they knew that I was his mother in in the former life, the mate, very Memorial teachings and our families in our life. So two very, very precious teachings. His teachings are very, very precious for our daily life practice.
Host 1:09:36
I'm also just thinking if I was in his place, and there was someone that was so close and so dear to me that that I had such a personal connection with and and passed away. And then I knew somehow with certainty that that this baby is that other being reborn, that's another level of kind of detachment and not because I would want to transfer All of my love and previous connection from another lifetime into this new life. And I would not want to let go of that other relationship, you know, I would want to everything that other relationship meant I would want to impose that onto the new relationship. Yeah, to not lose that feeling with how important that person had been to me. And yet, this, if you believe in karma, believe that this, this is a next lifetime. Even though it's a next lifetime, they have no memory or knowledge of who they were in a former relationship. So I put myself in their position and wonder how they would be able to relate to what is now their mother, but doesn't remember being their mother.
Zaw Win Htet 1:10:46
Yeah. As for me, I also do not have any memory. If I was his mother or not, I have no memory, only believing his sayings, and I have to make my life more beautiful and beautiful with the teachings or him and with the teachings of Buddha.
1:11:14
I found Zaza interview really interesting. Not only is he a wealth of information about his area, which you would expect of a guide, right? But the impressive thing is just understanding how Mima works and how he came to that, you know that that lovely relationship he had with his grandmother and that, you know, in that sense, it's like an oral tradition, and self taught, you know, and just that initiative he takes to like Google things, and just to learn, it's just it was such an inspiring story.
Host 1:11:43
Yeah, he's a really special guy, you know, I had met him online and corresponded for years when we he was helping with the guidebook project and learning about the region and the hometown and contributing that way. And I've met him several times since and really fortunate, he came to my place and the recording studio to do this interview, I'd been asking him for some time for that. And he's just a gem. I mean, he's such a, such an energy of brightness and, and good feeling, and just Dhamma wisdom and goodwill when you meet them. And I think a lot of that comes out. And I think also just the level of of memorization and how he's able to retain facts. You know, sometimes I read things and hear things they just especially when as we get older, they just go in one ear and out the other. And it's, it's just so impressive during this talk, how and this talk was not planned, it was not scripted. He didn't know what was coming. And it's basically this talk progressed. It's like, hey, so tell me about this. Hey, so tell me about this. Well, what about this one? And he just kind of takes a breath? And he's like, Oh, yeah, well, that's interesting, because this book said this, but my grandmother said this, but this monk I talked to said this, but then I thought about this, and I remembered the guy a minute ago who corresponded with this. And we have to say, this is not in a country that through the brutal dictatorship has had its educational system torn apart, as we learned with sway wins interview, right? This is not a skill you really come across in a lot of people is this high fascination of wanting to learn knowledge critically reflect on it, retain it be able, at the drop of a dime to be able to relay certain stories? You know, he's really an impressive guy.
1:13:18
Right, exactly. And the region he's from is really interesting, too. So to to have all those skills. And in that region, which is it's, by and large is kind of off the the tourist map of Western tourists, at least, you know, not many people go there, and it's rich in history. And then there's this gem of a guy who knows, like, so much about the area.
Host 1:13:40
Right, right. Yeah, exactly. And this was one of the places in the the meditators guidebook project that I led this region was was one of several that we put a lot of emphasis and focus in just in how and how important it was, even though it was off the beaten track. And there's a poem I'm looking for that what you said, reminded me of you said, it was kind of I can't remember the words you use, but it was a bit outside of our, of what people know. And there's this great poem by and I read an excerpt from it. It's from David Lambert, who is a meditator, and he went there on a pilgrimage with us and Guan Chi, I think it was when he visited, and wrote a poem about it. And there's this line describing monywa. And here it is, quote, beyond the conventional radar. This is the heart of Yogi tourism, where foreign meditators come to explore the heartland of their spiritual souls. For some, this is the area where it all began. That was a poem I always liked. I just love that area where it all began. And we'll get to the history of that of what I learned in that research. You know, it's funny because that region actually goes way back. And there's some historians that have suggested that the earliest human civilization in the entire region of that part of the world might have come from there, or at least one of the first few human communities was there. So it's really a place in the earliest forms of humans that can be traced back. But you know, today it's not a tourist town, like the thing it's most famous for is it's rough cotton blankets and raw bamboo. It's a trade hub for India. There's this design mon festival in November that's kind of famous for locals. But there's, there's really not much there. I think if you looked at a Lonely Planet, it would take a page or two of the sites for the normal tourists to see.
1:15:29
Right, what sounds like there's a lot of potential there. Yeah, well
Host 1:15:32
as we go on and trace the history. So Michael Charney is a scholar who's written a bid on it. And he's really done some good research and he called it quote one of Burma's political and cultural frontiers. And so that's a good image to have, as you're thinking of this history is kind of a frontier land something that was always a bit outside of the Weimar kingdom. And that was a meeting place of different tribes and different groups. Charney describes how they're the kitchen and Naga. These are ethnic groups, kitchen and Naga clans that would mainly keep to themselves, but they lived in kind of roamed in these areas. And then parts of the chin hills west of the river here and the chindwin. Were never under the dominion of Mr. King. So there's really been some independence and there's also been some shifting controls of who was in charge of it. So for example, there was like Sean says another ethnic group, Shaun King established himself north of the river, and even the Indian Kingdom of Manipur controlled parts of the Upper West Bank. So there were different peoples living and also different peoples that were controlling and leading this region as well. And the Bomar didn't arrive until really enforced until the mid 18th century. And most of them that came of that time or escaping the Anglo Burmese wars of the 18th and 19th century, that's when the Bomar arrived. And that brings us a little bit closer to modern history when the British took over and annexed the country. They made it their regional headquarters in 1886. And so what had always been this kind of remote wild land, this place where different tribes kept to themselves, but kind of mingled and now became this kind of frontier outpost of the British Empire.
1:17:22
Right. Hey, just for clarification, you know, that stone inscription that says, you know, that all these different ethnicities lived there, I was under the impression that they were all like, fully mingled, but they all basically it's more like they coexisted there, right? Or was it more like they came in waves of, of who was dominant there? Or, you know, can I be fleshed out a little bit?
Host 1:17:44
Right. So that's a really good question. And actually, I should clarify that I'm talking more about Manjula, which is the big city today in the region. And for the most part, za was talking about Chung woo and the little bogen area of Omnia, which is more of his his hometown, and his village and a little bygone village. Those have incredibly long histories. I mean, those have histories of 1000 2000 years. And even though these are pretty close to monywa, I'm relating more what I know about the monywa history. So as I described that plaque, it could have been a mingling in his village. And even though monywa was close by, they could have some kind of different history, but I don't know that would be a question for czas was this a sign of real intercultural development and these communities living together interacting together? Or were they separate in some way?
1:18:39
Right. Either way, I think it's interesting, though, right? I mean, because even the coexistence would be would be something and, you know, I guess you just see that in some places, even in Yangon, but, you know, between the, you know, and sleep here, you know, by pagoda there, you know, there's there's the Muslims and the and, and Buddhists there, I mean that those are not ethnicities race, so directly, but you know, there's a pretty peaceful coexistence there. So yeah, that's curious. But anyways, you have more, I still think, yeah, you know, a lot about Manjula.
Host 1:19:11
Yeah. And you know, in going back to just diversity in Myanmar, it's Myanmar has always been just such an incredibly diverse country. And this is relevant to the British taking over is that the British in their colonial system very much wanted to classify and categorize things, whether it was botany or animals or insects or ethnic groups. And so one of the criticisms in modern Burmese scholarship of the colonial period is that they really tried to put people in cultural ethnic boxes of identity that often were more fluid in terms of the way people actually lived. And so even the way we try to understand ethnicity now in me and Maher both today, as well as in times before, is kind of a superimposed British formal system onto something that was more fluid in nature, but in any case, Catching up to where the British were in 1886. When they made it their headquarters, It then became kind of like this regional outpost. So we should take a step back and kind of look at me and Mara as a whole. So there's always been these places in Myanmar where the conditions were not so ideal for actually people in civilization, but they attracted a certain kind of monastic. Because when you're talking about a Buddhist society, you're not just talking about conditions that are good for laypeople and society and economy and civilization and modernity to flourish. You're talking about a monastic following a very strict discipline, that are kind of looking for a different thing from society. Sometimes they're actually looking for conditions that are livable, but not really all that ideal or luxurious because it gives away to a certain type of practice. And monywa was one of those places. So even though the Bomar only came there very recently, and mainly as war refugees, and then as part of the colonial empire that was built up, monks have been coming to monument for the last 1000 years. At that time, it was a very remote forested place of practice where they could live in seclusion. There was a dense forest far from the capital, but maybe some well wishers and donors who would give to them on daily alms rounds. So it has this history of a really rugged and harsh place where only the Hardy went, actually, if I can give another quote by charny in describing just the severity of the land, he said, quote, the harshness of the chindwin environment, and its relatively low population base may have dissuaded all but the hardiest monks and quote, so it's always had a little bit of that history. It's always kind of interesting, because when monks might come to like a wild area, that's uncivilized. And they come there, because they don't want civilization, they want to be in this remote place of practice, where they can really work hard and work towards liberation, and maybe not be so comfortable in the body, but work for a greater comfort in the mind. But as they start to come to these places, and they start to gain renowned, more and more followers come and so they actually end up counter intuitively being this kind of civilizing agent over time. That's what happened here as well. And in monywa, there actually became a kind of competition between city and forest monks, the forest monks who came to live in these remote rugged places, and then the lay supporters that came to support them, and then the civilization they brought, and then the city monks who came to be closer to those lays that weren't venturing in the forest. And this became so fierce that on at least one occasion, there's record that it even spilled over into violence between the city and the forest monks. I'm not exactly sure what the nature of their dispute was. But this tension developed between these forest monks who would come to live ruggedly and then the city monks that act as more of a of a modernizing agent.
1:22:59
If I understand you correctly, you're saying that the fourth Knox came first, that must have been some small village there for support, right. And basically, you're saying that as they attracted more support and more people, then they became kind of the gateway to growth of the area, and then on the on the coattails of that come to city monks and establish themselves. And then over time, there's a kind of a feud between the two parties. Is that right?
Host 1:23:25
Yeah, I mean, this dichotomy between the city and the forest monks, this goes back to the Buddhist time, there's Pali words that I won't try to pronounce, because I'll probably mess them up. But there are Pali words that represent this dichotomy between what it was like to be a monk living in the city and supporting those lays closer to you and often living a more comfortable life and those forest monks who issued and avoided the more modern developments and just went to live by themselves and we, that's also a theme we see in the manual region is the the people that wanted to live the monks, the monastics that wanted to live a more rugged life and those that then came to settle in a more relaxed way among the city. Right. So anyway, what was really interesting is you have this kind of backwards remote region, this frontier land that would completely change the country in the 18th century, politically as well as monastics. So now we're going a bit before I'm going to describe what was happening monastic Lee a bit before the British came and then describe what happened a bit after they came. So we're on these kind of competing timelines. So interestingly, this was also a place that produced some of the best fighting men in the Bomar Empire, especially for King Botha Paya. Maybe because it was this rough, really harsh land and so it it not only did rugged monastics go there, but the people living there were some of the best fighting men in the Empire as well.
1:24:52
Right, like tough, tough places produce tough people. Right, exactly. Yeah,
1:24:57
good
Host 1:24:58
point. So What was interesting, though, in terms of the monastics, is there had been this, this point of contention between different schools of Burmese monks that was being argued for over a century. And I won't go into the details of that for a limited time. But monk after monk head, say it after head say it, King after King was trying to resolve this technical detail, and they weren't able to be successful until this time that some of these manual monks played a role in that. And they won this, this textual argument and their group became known as the to dama restoration and through today through Dhamma, is the biggest sect of Burmese monks. It's about 85%. So they are the orthodoxy today, and that orthodoxy was established by a very small group of manual monks, that basically stressed the importance of looking at the textual accuracy of the Scriptures and the Pali Canon. So rather than following the regional tradition of something, or the tradition of the villages, or what the older monks did, they argued that you had to go back to the sources in the scriptures. And so their way of looking at the practice and the monkhood and Buddhism as a whole became the orthodoxy from the 18th century on. And it was really this very small group of monks from the region that came from nowhere to win this argument and then become the orthodoxy. And Shawnee just does an excellent job of showing how these remote regions were able to gradually become the orthodoxy and set the standard for how monkhood and Buddhism were to be followed through today.
1:26:45
Right. That's fascinating. Yeah, I didn't know that. That background. Thanks.
Host 1:26:50
Yeah. And so that leads us further along the timeline. And, and actually, interestingly enough, those monks that stress that the textual accuracy known as the through dama, restoration, they themselves trace their lineage back to the forest, the early forest monks that came centuries earlier, to the monywa region. I don't know how accurate that was. But it's just, you know, obviously, it's a good look. But in any case, that leads us to the last point, which I think and what makes me so excited about this because I want to set up my last point and kind of build some some tension for what the big reveal is going to be for those that might not know. And that's that when you're a meditator today, and you just get this practice, you go to a course or you read a book or you you get some benefit from from this or that. You don't really know where it came from. You don't know the historical trajectory of how everything that came before landed with you. And that's what we're about to get to here. Because all of what I just said about the region, the dama restoration, the British, all of that paved the way for a young monk from monywa. Name a shin Janya, dada, who would one day walk into lady forest and take the name of Lady forest and become lady seda. So ladies say it grew up several decades after the two dama restoration had taken place. So he grew up in an environment where textual accuracy and adhering to the Pali Canon was the most important thing, this kind of scholarship. And as anyone who knows about lady say it as life would know, he was an avid reader, he consumed everything around him. And this was at a time when scholarship was the way to advance in the monkhood. And so his whole training was predicated on this group of monks from this region, all the more promoting this Dhamma restoration that became his world as he grew up as a young monk, Oxford say a contemporary monk has pointed out in an essay that he wrote a thesis statement that ladies say it have benefited from these more open scholastic opportunities that were emerging at the time. And that if he had grown up at a different time or place such as today because Oxford say it is very critical of the educational environment today, that ladies say it would not have become ladies say it. And as we also know, when or as some people know, maybe it's news for for meditators listening today, but in any case, when ladies say it or reach these great heights of academia and became one of the most famous and respected and even controversial, scholarly monks in the Royal capital of Mandalay, what did he do but left these heights of scholastic study to wander into a forest into a rugged forest, to live under trees to live in caves? And it's kind of like, you know, knowing this monywa history, it's like, you know, he had some monywa blood in him, he's this this he grew up in this rough, rugged environment and even as he became this great scholar, he went back into that and just to put a cap on it for those who who don't know who ladies say it is, he is in the lineage of SF Goenka so he taught ladies say at a taught siata ji who taught mobikin who taught going. And so Glink has worldwide mission of spreading the passion all around the world. And all the meditators who've benefited all the people who've come on the show, to talk about how much they've benefited from taking these courses and how they've gone deeper into Burma dama. All of this came from lady say it, as David Lambert said, this is where it all began with monywa. And what makes me so excited to tell the story is that we're not just talking about ladies say it, but we're talking about the decades and the centuries and even the 1000 years before ladies say it, I came on the scene to understand his environment and his culture and his context. And I think this is more than just intellectual entertainment. I think that knowing these things, really has us examine how we're part of this living history of trajectory that is still continuing through today and the story that's still being told.
1:30:56
Right, so not necessarily a lineage of practice, but an influence of style, both in the referencing the scriptures directly as as a source of authority, and also the style of being tough. I mean, that may be tough, not quite the right word there. But yeah, Hardy hardy monk. Yeah. And then living in the forest. And, and so that that inclination to want to be a forest monk and to live in more remote places, as well as the scriptural right influence? directly to the script, right. Yes. What is what that influences in? Yeah, that's great.
Host 1:31:34
Yeah, so interesting.
1:31:36
Yeah, that's cool. I think, when I was going comunitarios, always looking for just the, you know, the practice lineage, you know, what there's, and that's hard to find, if you go, you know, I mean, they're, they haven't found it yet, going back before lady, but nonetheless, these these influences are still important as far as other factors go.
Host 1:31:57
Right? Absolutely. And ladies say it didn't come from nowhere. He was influenced by his time and place by his contemporaries by a senior's bias culture. And so learning about the influences that may ladies say it inform the decisions, ladies say it a made and as his teachings eventually reached us, as meditators in whatever form or place or age we were, it just gives a greater context for how decisions were being made and how that transmission happened. So it's not like just this magic, like, oh, a 10 day courses here, I'm just gonna go and learn these things. But it actually gives us this kind of appreciation and curiosity for How did this get to that? Right,
1:32:41
I'm always supportive of relying on text for influence. You know, I think there were, you know, 1000s of years where we got away from that, you know, I mean, I was reflecting on, you know, Eric Brock's book really brought home the point, I just kind of didn't occur to me that like, without a printing press, right, you know, we take for granted now that we have, I mean, even before the internet, we had libraries, we had printed books, we had access to Scripture. And for 1000s of years, that wasn't the case. So you still see this, I mean, this kind of reminded me when I was listening to saw how he's learning from his grandmother. And that's kind of the beautiful part of oral tradition. And at the same time, like, it's recommended to compare what you're hearing from a teacher to what the Buddha said, and and really the only two areas where you could ever do that, or, in the time of the Buddha, or near the time of the Buddha were people, at least the people you're learning from, you know, we're learning directly from the Buddha. But after after a few generations that's lost. And all you have is this chain where, you know, it's all oral transmission, and there's, it's very difficult to cross check. You can go to other teachers, and kind of hear and maybe average out what, you know, if there's any discrepancies. But nowadays, we have the internet, you know, so you know, this is all kind of pre printing press, the printing press came to me, Mr. about, you know, during this lifetime, so that was one of the conditions.
Host 1:34:09
Yeah, right. And we should just give a shout out, you're referencing the Eric brown book called The Birth of insight, which is a fantastic book recommended reading for any listener, the birth of insight, and that is about the life and legacy of Lady seda. The book I was referencing here was Michael Charney, which is not so much about lady say it but more about the region and the background. That led to ladies say it, eventually being born and becoming a monk. But both these books are great resources for the meditator.
1:34:42
Right. airboss books great and combined with Chinese book, he really rounds out and give some kind of more full picture of not only Lenny's life, but what came before I think in a combination. It really fills things out and that's great. And you had mentioned earlier about zones. Being little vegan, this is a different topic, but you know, I wanted to, you know, I think about, I think about places like vegan and places where there's a lots of lots of pagodas. And, you know, I came in with an attitude of minimalism, you know, and, and seeing a kind of, almost like a decadence in and wasting of effort and time and money, you know, around these kinds of things. And that's changed, you know, like, I remember, well, it's actually still kind of mixed. So sometimes I think it can be overdone. But I remember the first time I came to Myanmar on a pilgrimage with going and, and other meditators from that tradition, and it was, it was magical. I mean, lots of different ways, right. So even though the mind was, the mind just couldn't be critical at that point, because going on a trip, and being so mindful with other people, and going through this, you know, I guess going to set it up to in a way that's almost like mystical, you know, like this land of Dhamma, you know, and then you go around those kind of that kind of filter on already and meditating with people and be surrounded with meditators. And then every hillside, you know, so even places that aren't as densely built up with pagodas as a place like pecan are a little bit gone. It seems like on every, you know, every other Hill, at least there's some golden spire. And they're just like these little anchors all throughout the country. You know, I live in Thailand, now it's the same thing. So you can you can kind of take it for granted after a while. But if I'm mindful of it, then I can use those as usual anchors or reminder, hey, Buddhism, hey, Tama, hey, awareness, I can use it as a cue to be aware. And so at that time on that trip, you know, just you know, we were on a bus driving, you know, a, for example, from Yangon to Mandalay and there, yeah, it's just even in the middle of nowhere, it seems like there'll be a temple, you know, up on the hill, you know, and it's just one of those, you know, we've talked about before in other interviews and stuff about the linear track of Western practice of just being about sitting and how you come to these traditional places. And there's a lot more ways to kind of round out the practice with other practices, you know, and other. So in that sense, pagoda building is a practice and it can have an effect of bolstering faith of reminding people of the teachings I mean, there's so many ways it could possibly affect people. And that becomes part of practice as well, part of your path. So yeah, I just wanted to say a little something about that. It's not so much, it can seem like decadence, but it's actually can be a beautiful and helpful thing. So but God, you know, 1000 years later, still, I'm not sure exactly how old it is. But you know, you know, centuries and centuries of inspiring people. And and even today, even people that are Buddhists, you know, they come there to visit and there's some sense of, there's something there for people.
Host 1:38:10
Yeah, it reminds me of after living in Myanmar for a couple years, I had the realization that every little hill, every little stump, every mountain, every cliff, every crag had a little pagoda on top. And when I started looking at other countries and traveling and other places, it's like well, usually, anywhere that you have a view or you have a bit of remoteness, that's where you have like the golf course or the mansion or the person with private property or something like that. So it's really the the more rich and elites that own those areas. Whereas in Myanmar, it's always a testament to the Buddhist teachings. And it's this place that's free and open for all it's often the the cleanest place in the area. It's the it's the quietest place, it's the place with often the least trash and you know, the nicest tiles and the biggest trees. And it's a place where anyone can come and get a bit of silence and a bit of meditation practice, if you want that you can sit in front of a Buddhist statue and you can meditate you can make offerings, you can recite sutas. You can take refuge in the precepts, any number of things. And it's this, the selfless giving of a donor who has provided this on top of the hill for then anyone rich or poor, to come and take advantage of this public place to deepen their faith. And it reminds me as well as the interview we had with Jose Molina on a recent podcast where he described so this was an American xpat meditator who left the country due to the coronavirus pandemic, everything shutting down. And once he was out of Myanmar, and after having lived there for a couple years, he realized that the absence of just not seen monastics on the street, which are also a testament in the faith in the Buddhist teachings, just like pagodas are that just being exposed to this no longer was harder for him. He would have imagined it would have been because these living testaments or, or structural testaments to the Buddhist teachings are this kind of constant reminder of the path and of the practice.
1:40:11
Right. And there's something to, even in this in a city, in the countryside or on top of a hill, you know, whatever it is, there's something about, like, you know, entering that kind of island of possible awareness, you know, but that, all that goes into that, you know, but even so, even just coming up to the perimeter of a place, and then you know, just taking a moment to take off your shoes and walk barefoot through the place, you know, there's just, it's almost like that act of stopping, take your shoes off and then entering the place. Fortunately, they are like, the cleanest places, you know, and a nice cool feeling tile on your feet, and then kind of slows me down, you know, and then I, I walk around, right.
Host 1:40:54
And looking at this history of taking shoes off at a pagoda. I refer largely to saving Buddhism, which is a book by Alicia Turner, who actually will be an upcoming podcast guest on this series. It's a great book, saving Buddhism, and she has a whole chapter on this issue of wearing shoes. So she relays in the book how the issue of wearing shoes on a pagoda platform is traced not to a foreigner, not to the British, but to one of the country's most famous monks in the late late 19th century, actually, this was oak Posada. And so linking back this to Dhamma orthodoxy that started in the manual region, which we referenced just a little earlier. Now to Dhamma has become this orthodoxy, they set the tone there the conservative faction and oppose it was a bit of a revolutionary reactionary monk. And he purposely wore his shoes on a pagoda to challenge the to dama way of doing things. His reason for doing so was that he was arguing that the mental intention was more important than the action. So in other words, because he did not have a mental intention to show disrespect, he was able to do an action which the orthodoxy had ruled disrespectful. So this revered, say it Oh, wore his shoes in the 1890s, at pagodas. And this was his reason for doing so. But what happened instead was this outcry that there was a challenge to the accepted norms. And this indicated that there was this precipitous and dangerous decline of the sasana. It was a warning cry that the Buddhist teachings are going to vanish in our lifetime because now we have monks that are just blatantly violating the respect by wearing their shoes around the pagoda. So this is actually where Alicia Turner begins her story of tracing wearing shoes at a pagoda and then it turned into something else as the decades followed.
1:42:53
Yeah, that's interesting, because I, I really have an issue with this idea of the assassin are falling apart for things like this, you know, like, I think why I like taking shoes off. And I, I do think it's a good reminder, I do think that conservativism can go too far to the point where you're following rules and think if you don't, things fall apart, and you're actually not aware, and you've lost that discernment of whether there's an awareness, and what is the intention, and what is really the most important thing. So, yeah, you can wear shoes on a pagoda platform in a disrespectful way. And you can also just not be mindful of it. It's not that that's not then disrespectful. I think it's kind of an economy of mind to just rely so heavily on rules. But the whole point of Dhamma isn't, isn't that kind of economy of mind, it's to is to bring awareness to things and look into them deeper, you know, and to understand how things work, you know, so the sosna declines when we lose awareness, and that ability to discern and gain wisdom, rather than, you know, I think I think it goes so far now is it's like, hey, these are the rules. This is the way to do it. And you know, the sosna is following these rules and assassin and breaks when you don't, you know, and if you don't, it's disrespectful. I think that I think to control the masses, maybe that's maybe that's useful. But as far as the damage goes, it's about you know, like, looking into things and having discernment. So I have some issue with with those conservative ideas.
Host 1:44:34
Yeah, and it's definitely interesting, because another theme we're seeing in this talk is things that are relevant today. We're also relevant 100 years ago, we're also relevant 1000 years ago, we're also relevant during the Buddhist time. So these are fundamental themes that are contrast to spiritual society and society. And in any case, to continue the story. So the next thing that happens is there's this Irishman monk dama loca and actually a biography is just been written about him by Alicia Turner and Lawrence Cox. And that's another future episode that we have planned to interview Lawrence and hear more about dama loco, which I'm very excited about. He's one of the first Westerners as socialists, that ordained in Myanmar. In any case, he confronted this Irish monk. Late 19th century, early 20th century confronted an off duty Indian policeman who was wearing shoes at a pagoda festival, and udaan A loca also framed the argument following the criticism of oak Posadas act in which the wearing of shoes at a Buddhist holy site was seen as kind of an overt attack on the Buddhist teachings that needed to be defended fully in order to support the strength of Asana. So now it starts to become after these two acts, it's in the minds of people as like something that is associated with the survival of the assassin. And so then at this point, different Burmese groups are taking up the cause. And they start putting pressure on on local pagoda trustees all over the country to prevent anyone from wearing shoes at the pagodas. This was a change of course from previous practice. So now signs start to go up at various pagodas where the trustees agree with this or are pressured into it, that are are announcing that no one can contribute to the downfall of the sasana by wearing their shoes at these pagoda sites,
1:46:31
as the Buddha wanted to focus on, on whether you wear shoes or not like is that the sauce enough? Right?
Host 1:46:40
Right. Right. So now enter the Europeans into the mix because of course the British are controlling the country. And some of the Europeans did relent. And they saw this as kind of an act of basic kindness and respect to another country's customs. It said today you know you walk into a European church you take your hat off, you walk into a Burmese pagoda you take your shoes off, this is just the custom that you do and depending on where you are. But the the Buddhist carried on in the fear, this was really a decline of this Asana. And they felt that any person of any religion would suffer bad karma for showing disrespect. For the Buddhist particularly this could generate a communal bad karma that would be simultaneously carried by all and would degrade the Buddhist teachings for everyone. So this was like if Buddhists and non Buddhists continued to walk on pagoda grounds with shoes, that would develop into a communal bad karma that would seriously threaten the survival of the saucer. And so this was a fundamental difference that Alicia Turner points out that even though the European non Buddhists, and the Burmese Buddhist might have a similar view, in not wanting to wear shoes, at pagodas, their reasons for those views that they're holding are quite different depending on their background.
1:48:01
Yeah, on the one hand, I'm actually totally in support of taking shoes off. And yet, I very much sympathize with Opus siata. Because I think and I think his point was lost it, you know, now he can so easily become about wearing shoes or not wearing shoes, and it kind of crystallizes around that, and then the DOM is not there anymore. And, you know, I have a feeling that he was trying to shake that up and go back to discernment of, of the Dhamma of intention, for example. So I think it is polite to when you especially when you visit other countries to to follow their customs and be respectful. And in that sense, I and I've already talked about how I like to take my shoes off, you know, and I think the British had really tall boots, right? They didn't want to unlace them all or that I've heard something like that, but I wear flip flops. It's easy.
1:48:55
Exactly.
Host 1:48:56
Yeah, well, that that leads to the next point. So this is where things really come to a head because so the years 1916 you have thing nouns and attorney as well as a trustee of a pagoda and ProAm. Now PA, which is in kind of Central Myanmar, and he installed a sign stating that all visitors with no exceptions must remove their footwear. This was just a local trustee, a local pagoda trustee following this kind of religious nationalist norm that was starting to take place and take shape. But what happened was the British viceroy was due to visit the town where this particular pagoda had this sign and was told by the authorities that they were following the guidance of the trustee. And so now you have a situation where a British viceroy is visiting the small pagoda and is being asked to remove issues this is a big deal and what to do and the colonial government they tried to censor discussion in the editorial pages of the newspaper prior to the visit because they didn't want bad press and they also they The British government after some of the problems in India 5075 years earlier, they had this policy of trying to be neutral in religious matters anywhere in the world, they were colonizing, just to not take sides and to try to be neutral in it. But now you really have things coming to a head with this viceroys visit. And this was picked up this this issue and this potential confrontation was picked up by the why MBA, which is the young man's Buddhist Association influenced by the YMCA in the West. And they took on this issue to adapt a country wide campaign that the British should prevent anyone from any background from any position from wearing shoes at any pagoda site. This is then becoming this kind of rallying call of the nationalist why MBA, which general Aung San who became the first leader of Burma after goddess independence, obviously, the father of unsung Suchi. This became a rallying cry to protect their religion, protect their culture, protect their sosna to stop anyone from wearing shoes at a pagoda site. And this became one of the tenants of the nationalist movement and still a very sensitive thing today, obviously, that one should not wear shoes at any pagoda site. And this is some of the background where it came from. And of course, we Zahra was a nationalist monk from this region Rizal came from Zod talks about his biography, and one of his core principles was this. But in telling where we got today, the really interesting thing that I got from Alicia Turner's book is where they started from, I never would have guessed that it was this revered monk who was protesting against the orthodoxy. And doing so in this kind of weird, awkward way of wearing shoes intentionally a pagoda to try to prove a point that that was actually the impetus for how it developed into this nationalist movement that took on a much different tone and tenor. And that still today, and one never would have thought where it would have come from. Yeah, it illustrates a point. I
1:52:06
just think it's ironic because actually, the Seattle, I think if we look into what he was doing, it wasn't, I mean, nowadays, it's become just about wearing shoes or not wearing shoes, and he wore shoes, therefore he was disrespectful. And I think the whole point was lost. And actually, the irony of it here is I think, losing that discernment of being able to look into what's really going on somewhere losing that is losing the sosna. Because that's what the teacher, that's what the teaching is. So it's like, you know, I think it's just an interesting illustration of how someone is actually trying to help get back to the essence of the Dhamma is then ostracized as an enemy of the dominant over the sosna.
Host 1:52:56
Right, right. Yeah. A lot of twists and turns.
1:53:00
You mentioned, as well. And he's, he's held up, I think you I think he was said that he's held up as sort of a role model for modern nationalist Is that right? Yeah. And I don't know, I don't know enough about his history. But you know, there's this idea of, you know, whether monks should be involved in politics or not, and they hold up certain acts of the past, in order to justify being involved politically. So I don't know, with her us case, but there are times when we're actually protecting Buddhism. And there are times when we're actually getting involved for the welfare of the people it is I don't think I never read anywhere in the scriptures. And I've read the vineya and studied it for years. I don't see anywhere where it that that's the role of a monk is to take care of the general welfare of the people of a country. The role of monk is to, as far as I understand it, is to go deep into study and practice so they can be free of suffering, and in that welfare of the people, helping people to whatever their proclivity is to come out of suffering as well. Right? And so, you know, if they lose, if there's an actual physical threat to Buddhism, then they might, you know, in a very skillful way, learn how to engage with that, but then if that's not necessarily the case, you know, so I don't know if wizards was railing against an actual threat to to dama or, or just getting involved in politics. You know, I think there's a clear line you know, there's there's a reason that that you're not supposed to get involved in politics. You're not supposed to hold any kind of offices, you know, that kind of thing and you're not, you'd be careful about how you meet with people in office to like, There's a rule about not meeting with people in high offices in private, you know, because you come out of that as a monk, and people see you in with that person in private and then that officer or that that person in politics and government might then make a big decision that affects everyone. And there's a correlation there. But they may have made that decision had nothing to do with you talking together. But people will think that, or could think that. So you have to be careful about who you meet and how you meet them even so even at that level, monks had to be careful.
Host 1:55:31
Yeah, right. And when you mention how monks are only told to really get involved when the sausage was threatened? Well, that's all in the eye of the beholder. And one of the great things that Alicia Turner does in her book saving Buddhism is to describe how basically, through many periods of Bernie's history, there's been these cycles, where, if it's not this, it's that if it's not that it's something else, that something external is seen as the reason why the entire Senate is in danger and is, and therefore becomes justifiable to take some certain action in order to save the country in the golden land, from the Buddhist teachings from disappearing. So this is this is really all very much in the eye of the beholder. and assessing how how dangerous the threat really is, or if it's just kind of a cyclical thing that every generation a new, a new situation comes along, which is seen as as a existential danger.
1:56:25
Right. And that's it. That's the thing about this. It's not it's not just a specific event, it's it's a thing that happens over and over again. And, again, the truth there is like, I I appreciate what it can do through people's faith to kind of get involved and think they're protecting the sosna. But the irony there, again, is like often I think these things, I think it convinces lots and lots of people that they're protecting the sauce, lemon sauce is important. And in that sense, it's good. But then at the same time, the way they think the dam is, or the assassin is being damaged, or lost versus upheld and maintained and sustained. In you know, what, what's really going on is the things that really matter are deteriorating in perhaps even more so sometimes by these because these things tend to eclipse, they're out front, and they tend to eclipse or you know, people tend to forget about the essence and focus more on these things. And then the essence of Dhamma is lost, and then the damage loss. I mean, that's how that's how I see it at least.
Host 1:57:28
Yeah, sometimes the cure can be worse than the illness.
1:57:33
Yeah, well, yeah,
1:57:34
you were in this case, it's like, the the cause of the illness isn't seen and the cure actually doesn't doesn't hit the mark. Matter of fact, it Yeah. It obfuscates the ability to see the real deterioration of the fastener.
Host 1:57:50
Yeah, yeah, absolutely. I know we're a little long on this one, but I hope it's justifiable. This was just such an interesting history of this region czar just sparked so much of my own curiosity and fascination and wanting to share maybe nerd out a little bit and hope that listeners are at least half as engaged as I am and sharing it. But I do want to wrap up and just share one personal thing that I found quite interesting. That was the story that Zod told about the dead dog being placed on the table where Bodie the town said I was eating. And that was kind of a I asked saw what the purpose of that was. And that was kind of like a, you know, a practice in not being attached to food and seeing impermanence right in front of you, all these things together. And so what was interesting for me, though, is that when I was doing the conversation with za, I was reading a book called mindful America. Sorry, I don't have the author's name in front of me. But it was basically about how the meditation movement had come to the US and kind of been watered down and integrated into local culture and used in ways that was more accommodating what people wanted. And there was a whole section on eating in the book and the author illustrated how the dama messaging the mindfulness messaging, on eating rather than then talking about how one shouldn't enjoy the food or should should not relish it, it's just part of sustenance. And you think of this really grotesque and intense example the body tongue say it up, they would talk about how when you're mindful, you better enjoy your food, you enjoy it even more because you're aware how to avoid overeating because there's an abundance of food for for meditators who are usually middle class or better, and how to not have so much craving that you just eat neat, neat, and you're then you're unhealthy, how to purchase organic and sustainable products. And he points out that a lot of the Dhamma instructions on eating are actually geared more with females in mind more female audiences, and they assume a problem of abundance. Rather than insufficiency. And so I'm reading this chapter on in mindful America on how eating and mindfulness with eating has been reimagined and repurposed for an American populace. And then I'm hearing zawe story about a dead dog whose body is rotting, put on a lunch table of Bodhi that sounds sad to contemplate the role of food and the role of impermanence and inevitable death and everything else. And so this was just such a fascinating moment of the juxtaposition between how the west and the east how Burma and the US are taking in a similar subject of mindful eating, and just going in very different directions with it. And, you know, it's very hard to imagine a new age self help style mindfulness book in America today, recommending that you place a dead dog on your lunch table as a meaning of observing your sustenance.
2:01:01
Yeah, maybe you should write that book.
Host 2:01:06
Yeah, not for me not I don't think in this climate.
2:01:10
Well, yeah, I don't think necessary that all the western advice on eating is so off the mark, you know, that idea of enjoyment? Those I think, I think that goes too far. And I just don't think I wonder how that that is even taught because when, when I'm aware, when I'm eating, I just realized what a chore it is. And so I realized that how I perceive things is enjoyable. It's usually because there's a burst of good flavor, which is pleasant. And then the mind wanders off and doesn't really pay attention anymore until the next big burst that kind of intrudes on the thought. And then the overall impression is like, Wow, this is great. But like when I just aware the whole time I'm eating, it's a chore. And then naturally, I don't want to overeat. It's not like I don't enjoy it or think it's disgusting, but I just realized, like, Hey, this is a lot of work, actually, to have to do. Like, every day, some people three times a day or more, you know, I only eat once a day lately, but anyways, yeah, maybe we could use a few more dead dogs on our dominant table while we're eating.
Host 2:02:11
Boy. Yeah, I'd like to see that teaching.
2:02:16
We can open a center. I'm not sure how popular it would be though.
Host 2:02:20
Yeah, okay. I think I'll leave that to you. In any case, it's been a it's been a great talk.
2:02:26
So this has been Darwin part one, there is a part two coming so people look out for that we'll see you then.
Host 2:02:38
I'd like to take a moment to describe what our aim was in creating this podcast series. Our motivation is reflected by the in depth discussions we have with a wide range of guests in three categories of related information. First, we hope to educate and motivate listeners in their own practice, through the inspiring individual lives of meditators sharing their experiences and perspectives within the Burma Dhamma. Second, we want to help meditators in gaining a deeper understanding of the history of Myanmar, such as its context, culture, and religion, so that they can better appreciate how and where their own practice fits into the golden lands, which Dhamma history. We do this through interviews around scholarly works related to Buddhist Burma. And finally, we hope we can help listeners gain a deeper appreciation of the richness of current Burmese Buddhist issues, and how Buddha Dhamma has manifested in the golden land, which we get through a catch all category of potpourri of developments that can help shine a light on modern Myanmar, particularly its Buddhist context. Well, those are our goals, and we hope you found value in this particular show. If so, I want to bring up a gentle reminder that there is a minimum cost associated with every episode, and we are 100% listener supported. If you would like to hear more content, like the show you just heard now, please take a moment to consider giving a donation to keep our engine running. If you would like to join in our mission to share the Dhamma from the cold and land more widely. We welcome your contribution in any form, currency or transfer method. Every set goes immediately and directly to sustaining the programming. You can give right on our website via credit card by going to Insight myanmar.org slash donation or through PayPal by going to paypal.me slash Insight Myanmar. We also take donation through Patreon Venmo, GoFundMe and cash app. In all cases, simply search Insight Myanmar on each platform and you'll find our account. Alternatively, you can also visit our website for specific links to any of these respective accounts. Or feel free to email us at info at Insight myanmar.org in all cases, that's Insight Myanmar one word spelled i n si gh t ny a and Mar if you would like to give in another way please contact us. Thank you for your kind consideration. You have been listening to the Insight Myanmar podcast, we would appreciate it very much if you would be willing to rate review and or share this podcast, every little bit of feedback helps. If you are interested, you can subscribe to the Insight Myanmar podcast on Apple podcasts, Spotify, Stitcher or wherever else you get your podcasts. Also, please check out our website for a list of our complete episodes including additional text videos and other information at www dot Insight myanmar.org that's Insight Myanmar one word i en si gh TMYAN Mar. If you cannot find our feed on your podcast player, please let us know and we will ensure that it can be offered there. There was certainly a lot to talk about in this episode. And we'd like to encourage listeners to keep the discussion going. Make a POST request specific questions and join in our discussions on the Insight Myanmar podcast Facebook group. You are also most welcome to follow our Facebook and Instagram accounts by the same name of Insight Myanmar. And if you're not on Facebook, you can also message us directly at Burma dhamma@gmail.com. That's b u r m A d hamma@gmail.com. And we're also active on Dharma wheel. If you'd like to start up a discussion group on another platform, let us know and we can share that form here. Finally, we're open to suggestions about guests or topics for future episodes. So if you have someone or something in mind, please do be in touch. We would also like to take this time to thank everyone who made this podcast possible, especially our two sound engineers, Martin combs and darnay. There's of course that Kessler content collaborator and part time co host, Ken pranskey helps with editing. Drago spent DITA and Andre Francois produce original artwork and a special Mongolian volunteer who was asked to remain anonymous does our social media templates. We'd also like to thank everyone who assisted us in arranging for the guests we have interviewed so far. And of course, we send a big thank you to the guests themselves for agreeing to come and share such powerful personal stories. Finally, we are immensely grateful for the donors who made this entire thing possible. We also remind our listeners that the opinions expressed by our guests are their own and not necessarily reflective of the host or other podcast contributors. Please also note, as we are mainly a volunteer team, we do not have the capacity to fact check our guest interviews. By virtue of being invited on our show there's a trust that they will be truthful and not misrepresent themselves or others. If you have any concerns about the statements made on this or other shows, please contact us. This recording is the exclusive right of Insight Myanmar podcast and may not be used without the expressed written permission of the podcast owner, which includes video audio written transcripts and excerpts of any episodes. It is also not meant to be used for commercial purposes. On the other hand, we are very open to collaboration. So if you have a particular idea in mind for sharing any of our podcasts or podcast related information, please feel free to contact us with your proposal. As you know our podcasts are 100% listener supported. We welcome your contribution in any amount, denomination and transfer method you may give via patreon@patreon.com slash Insight Myanmar via paypal@paypal.me slash Insight Myanmar or by credit card by going to Insight myanmar.org slash donation. In all cases that's Insight Myanmar one word I N si gh T, NY and Mar if you'd like to give especially to support our new run of Coronavirus episodes, please go on the GoFundMe site and search Insight Myanmar to find our campaign. If you are in Myanmar and would like to give a cash donation please feel free to get in touch with us. Thanks and see you next show.