Playing with Dolls

In another controversial cartoon by JMP with sharp religious commentary, one Burmese woman is expressing concern to another, saying, "Are you sure your son is okay? All day long he talks to his doll, and even feeds it. Should we consult a doctor?" The irony, of course, is that the woman are bowing before a Buddhist alter in their home, where they are also likely "feeding and talking to" their Buddha image.

JMP is thus offering a biting critique of Burmese Buddhist culture, mocking the Buddhist rituals that emphasize the sacred of the shrine. The practice of showing respect to Buddha images can be understood from different perspectives. On one hand, which is likely the perspective JMP is drawing from, these Buddhist practices can be seen as placing too great a priority on superficial customs, which in many cases is derived more from cultural conventions than anything in Buddha's teachings 2500 years ago. JMP is thus projecting his criticism onto those Burmese Buddhists who take on the more superficial parts of Buddhism while not engaging in the deeper, more transformative aspects. Thus the mockery in comparing their image worship to a child playing with dolls.

However, I would be uncomfortable supporting such a critique writ large, without first delving into the greater nuance found in the different mindsets that may exist in following such a practice. Because for some, these offerings do not "replace" the deeper spiritual teachings of the Buddha, but in fact support them. If one is aware of the mental state when making these offerings, and when it is done with humility and gratitude for the spiritual path that the Buddha has laid out, such an act can also develop wholesome states of mind.

There is indeed much nuance and complexity when it comes to Buddhism in Myanmar, and it's important to take the time to properly understand the range of experiences before taking on the low-handing fruit of launching into easy criticism. Still, even where JMP's takes may lack this nuance, his is an important voice looking critically at aspects of his religion and society at a time of revolution.